Chatsky dangantaka zuwa Sophia. Shin Sophia soyayya Chatsky cancanta?

"Bone ya tabbata daga wit" - wani Multi-faceted samfurin. Ana iya gani da kuma zamantakewa parody da zargi na gwamnatin, da kuma tarihi zane na hali. Ba karshe wuri a cikin littafin ne rikici da kuma soyayya. Chatsky hali zuwa Sofya, su ji - da zuciyar cewa hidima a matsayin tushen ga labarin, ya cika ransa da motsin zuciyarmu.

Haruffa ta hanyar da idanu na dalibai

Nazari "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" na iya zama iyaka. La'akari da raba mãkirci motsa tare da wani girman siffar gilashi, to collate Quote from memoirs na Sahaban, da kuma tarihin rayuwa na zargin prototypes. Amma wannan dabarar ne mai sana'a Analyst, da wallafe-wallafen sukar lamiri. A makaranta darussa aikin da aka karanta sosai daban. Kuma bincikar daidai da shawarwari na methodical wallafe.

Akwai wasu irin haka da cewa ma'aikatar ilimi a kai a kai yayi dalibai fahimtar juna da m muqala rubutu: "Cancanta Shin Sophia Chatsky soyayya?", "Shin, Karenina Rights aka yankan shawara game da kisan aure?", "Faye hali na Prince Myshkin da hali." An ba da share abin da shi yake so ya cimma tsarin ilimi. Irin wannan bincike ne a gaskiya kõme ba su yi tare da adabi ya aikata ba. Yana ne wajen wani monologue kaka a ƙofar, suka yi shawara, idan Claudia da yake daidai daga uku Apartment idan harba Vaska-giya, ko har yanzu ba dama.

Kuma kwarewa dalibi na 9th aji wuya ba wani nuni ne na yadda da shi ya zama dole a shigar da harafin. Abu ne mai wuya ya za su iya fahimta cewa annoys Sophia a Chatsky kuma me ya sa. Fãce, ba shakka, da bayyane abubuwa - wadanda aka ambata da heroine kanta.

Features na ji plays

gargajiya fassarar "Bone ya tabbata daga wit" daga cikin play ne kamar haka hanya. Chatsky - akida, m kuma uncompromising. Na yanayi - mutane low, kunkuntar shiryayye kuma ra'ayin mazan jiya, bã su fahimta kuma kada ku riƙi wani ci-gaba, m akidar protagonist. Chatsky watsa shirye-shiryen, fallashi da kuma sa fun, kalma reeks al'umma mũnãnan ayyuka, kuma jama'a writhing da kyau-da nufin hit, Bears sharri da kuma fushi.

Yana da wuya a ce ko wannan sakamako nemi Griboyedov. Akwai kawai kishiyar version, bayanin play tsarin da m monologues-Rokon na protagonist kawai saboda marubucin parodied image na wani sassaucin ra'ayi, da yawa daga magana, kuma kome ya aikata ba. Kuma a hanyoyi da dama halayyar Sophia da Chatsky m daidai da yadda mai karatu tsinkayen samfurin. A cikin farko idan ya ga gwarzo idealist kuma ba mai godiya ga hasken dake fitowa Bafilisten, a karo na biyu - windbag demagogue ... kuma har yanzu ba zata auna gusts Bafilisten. Shin wannan gaskiya ne?

Details batu collisions

Wane ne Chatsky da Sophia? Shi - ashirin da daya, ta kasance - goma sha bakwai. Mun m har shekara uku da suka wuce. Chatsky tafi da zaran zo na shekaru, ya bar gidan majiɓinci, kuma ya koma zuwa ga iyali estate. Ban zo, bai rubuta. Just tsince kuma ya bace. Domin duk abin da dalili - shi ne ba da muhimmanci. Amma abin da dole ne jin soyayya goma sha huɗu yarinya a lokacin da mutumin da ta gan ta lover, ta nan gaba ango, don haka kawai daukan kuma ganye? Ba a mako, ba mai wata. Domin shekaru uku. Ko a talatin da shi - babban lokaci. Kuma a goma sha huɗu - har abada. Abin da aka ya yi duk da cewa lokaci? Wanda ake tunanin? Yana iya tabbatar da cewa da soyayya shi ne har yanzu yana da rai?

A goma sha huɗu-m shekaru, tare da matashi maximalism, matashi tausaya. Masu sukar na show ga yarinya ikirarin cewa ba kowane adult mace gana. Amma da hali Chatsky zuwa Sofia - ba wani shakka batu. Ya isa su yi tunanin wani halin da ake ciki ta hanyar da idanu na yarinya, ba da ganin abu duka karatu wanda Griboyedov duk duk gaya. Ba ma'ana ya tambaye: amma ya kamata shi ma Sophia ajiye akalla wasu ji for Chatsky? Kuma idan haka - me ya sa? Ya s ba miji, ba ango. Ya - wani romantic sha'awar, a daya batu uporhnuvshy son malam daga filin na shekaru uku. Wani tunanin ya kasance. Ji. Outraged girma. Kuma ta? Ta dã ba mu kasance a cikin irin wannan halin da ake ciki don jin wata cũta, bewilderment, fushi? Takaici karshe? Penelope, ba shakka, jiran Odysseus tsawon yawa - amma halin da ake ciki da aka quite daban-daban. Chatsky - nisa daga Odysseus.

Sofia closeup

Amma shi ke nan a bayan al'amuran. Hakika, m karatu zai fahimci duk abin da idan tunãni, amma halin da ake ciki ne har yanzu kawota tare da alamu, ta fizge na tattaunawar, tunanin. Zaka iya da kyau elude wani mutum saba ganin kawai babban labarin layi na samfur. Kuma abin da yake a can?

Chatsky ba zato ba tsammani ya koma zuwa ga mai kula da gidan, inda akwai ba har shekara uku. Ya ya ruɗe shi, ya kasance a jira, yana farin ciki. Halayen Chatsky zuwa Sophia zauna guda. Amma ta ya riga a soyayya tare da wani. Da farko, ko da yara, soyayya manta. Ta shi ne Keen Molchalin. Alas, da zabi ne mai kyau qwarai. Ma'ana - shi matalauci ne, m aji, yana da wani fili misalliance. Kuma ya subjectively - flabby sycophant, flatterer da insignificance. Ko da yake, ya kamata a lura, da al'amurra shi quite mai kyau. MOLCHALIN riga ya fara yin aiki kuma copes tare da aiki. Yana iya zaci cewa sabon zaba Sophia zai tafi da nisa

A wannan yanayin, matasa mutum da kansa ba ya son, ya ji tsoro kawai don shigar da shi. Kuma da hange na riba aure, ma, domin tabbatar, shi ne kyakkyawa sosai. Sau da yawa wannan shine m zabi na ana zargi ga yarinya, amsa tambaya, ko ya cancanci soyayya Sophia Chatsky? Ya yi musayar mikiya a kan fizge sparrow, wawa.

Kuma wãne ne Sophia? A yarinya wanda ya girma har ba tare da wata uwa, kulle up, kusan ba tare da barin bakin ƙofar gidan. Ta da'irar abokai - da uba wanda yana da wani ra'ayin game da ilimi na yara a general da kuma musamman 'ya'ya mata da kuma wata baranya. Sofia zai san game da maza? Ta yaya za ta akalla da wasu kwarewa? Kawai tushen bayanai - littattafai. Ladies 'Faransa litattafan, wanda damar ta karanta Papa. Kamar yadda wata yarinya iya sa fitar da mutum insincerity, shi ya shiga da amincewa da yafi balagagge kuma gogaggen mutane? Yana kawai ba gaskiya bane.

Sophia ne sosai matasa, ta ne butulci, romantic bai gogu da duniya. MOLCHALIN - kawai wani saurayi, wanda ta gani kusan a kowace rana. Shi matalauci ne, gaskiya, mai baƙin ciki, m kuma m. All guda, kamar yadda a cikin labari, wanda ya karanta Sofia kowace rana. Hakika, ta kamar ba zai iya taimakawa, amma fada cikin soyayya.

Kuma abin da Chatsky?

A wannan da hankali ne cancanci ma Chatsky hali. Ko irin kuskure tsirfanci Sophia? Idan ka dubi halin da ake ciki da ma'ana - ko babban rashi a rayuwar ta, wannan auren?

Chatsky ashirin da daya. A wuri bai same shi. Kokarin da shi, na kokarin a nan. Amma ... "Yana zai zama farin ciki mariri sickening." A matsayin cewa zai shige bukatun, har yanzu ba zai iya fadin zo. Kan abin da ake nufi da rai Chatsky? Ya na da wani Estate. Kuma, ba shakka, da serfs. Wannan shi ne babban tushen samun kudin shiga daga cikin matasa masu sassaucin ra'ayi. Mutumin da ya karfinsa da gaske kushewa serfdom, ya kira dabbanci da kuma mummunan kisa. Irin wannan shi ne funny matsala.

Shin Chatsky al'amurra? Career ya aikata ba, a fili. Babu soja - ya kasance ba wawa martinet. Kuma kudi - shi ne ba mai shago. Kuma siyasa - ya ba zai ci amanar akida. Wani Demidov ya ma bai zama ba - irin riko. Chatsky waɗanda suka yi magana, ba na waɗanda suka aikata.

Da suna da aka riga aka lalata, jama'a ne a guje daga gare shi kamar annoba. Yana da matukar ila cewa duk rayuwa Chatsky zai zauna a cikin iyali sunan, lokaci-lokaci barin mura da kuma babban birnin kasar. Wannan m Sophia a Chatsky yanzu, zai cigaba ne kawai, tare da shekaru, ya zama ko da mafi caustic da cynical, exasperated da m setbacks da kuma acin rai. Za a iya aure da wani mutum dauke da wani cin nasara jam'iyyar? Kuma ko Sophia farin ciki tare da shi - kamar adam farin ciki? Ko da shi Chatsky yake ƙaunar da zai ci gaba da wannan soyayya? Da kyar. Zai yiwu ban tausayi denouement daga cikin play kawai ga protagonist. Sofia kawai sa'a. Ran mutum.

Kuma a cikin halitta na tambaya

Duk da yake, a lokacin da rabo Chatsky Sofya tattauna a cikin hanyar: ko shi ne ya cancanci irin wannan mai girma soyayya kuma duk da haka ba - wannan a kanta ne m. Unethical. Shin yana yiwuwa ya zama cancanci soyayya? Wannan ne premium? Promotion? SHEDAN na wani post? Suna son ba ga wani abu, kamar wani dalilin. Saboda da bukatar ne wannan mutumin, kuma babu wanda kuma. Wannan rayuwa. Kuma babu soyayya ba tilasta ta abu ya fuskanci juna ji. Alas. The tambaya da kanta ba shi da inganci. Saboda haka ba shi yiwuwa. Son - ba dankali a kasuwa, ya ce ko yana da daraja da cewa mata request. Har yara ma ya kamata a fili kasance san wannan, ba a ma maganar da mazan mutane.