Review daga cikin littafin "Shantaram" Gregori Devida Roberts. Description mãkirci kuma siffofin samfurin

A 2010, da Rasha, da harshen da aka fassara littafin "Shantaram," Gregory David Roberts. Guest karatu ne bambancin: daga daukaka zuwa sharply korau. Mene ne ra'ayin sukar da Australian marubucin? Wannan shi ne iya kawo a cikin wannan labari, da kuma cewa, a maimakon haka, sa wani mummunan ra'ayi? Review daga cikin littafin "Shantaram" - jigo na wannan labarin.

A 'yan kalmomi game da marubucin

Daya jarida da kuma tafiya lover, da barin wani nazari a kan littafin "Shantaram", inda ya bayyana ra'ayin cewa, aikin Roberts tsiwirwirinsu Popularity a Rasha saboda jigo na ruhaniya ci gaba. Bayan duk, shi da aka tashe a littafan, babban Rasha litattafansu. Daya zai iya buga dama dalilai da nazari na littafin "Shantaram," suka ce a kasar mu, ya fi na yabo. Amma mafi game da cewa daga baya. Da farko, 'yan kalmomi ya kamata a ce game da marubuci, wanda biography ya tushen da labari.

Wani mazaunin garin na wani m zafi Australia bayan kisan aure da matarsa, da rabuwar da ya ƙaunataccen ya san wahalar Loneliness. Rabu da mu da rashin nishaɗi da ya yanke shawarar amfani da kayan haram kwayoyi. A sakamakon haka, ya rasa gaba daya da ikon komawa zuwa iyali arziki, amma samu tabar heroin buri. Wannan Australian ya kõwa fãce Roberts - marubucin acclaimed labari "Shantaram."

Littafi (reviews, kwatancin)

A mãkirci ayyukan inseparably nasaba da tarihin marubucin. Domin samar da kansu tare da illicit da kwayoyi, Robert fara fashi masu ba da bashi, yi da kamfanoni da shaguna. Ya aikata da laifin peculiar: ihu ba, ba barazana ko amfani da jiki da tashin hankali. Robert ya fitar da wani abun wasa gun da kuma musamman m don bayyana bukatunsu. Amma Roberts aka bai da wani lokaci har yanzu babba: goma sha tara da shekaru a kurkuku. Daga kurkuku marubucin "Shantarama" gudu zuwa India. A wannan asali aljanna kasar da kuma can sun kasance aukuwa cewa kafa tushen da littafin.

Daya miliyan kofe - wannan edition da labari "Shantaram." Reviews na littafin shahara mutane a koyaushe taka muhimmiyar rawa a cikin saye da samfurin. Roberts a kan murfin da labari za ka iya ganin view of Jonathan Carroll. American almarar kimiyya marubuci ya bar wani nazari na littafin "Shantaram", a cikin abin da ya bayyana ra'ayin cewa samfurin shi ba zai iya taimakawa, amma son. A cewar shi, ba su da sha'awar a "Shantaram" iya zama wani heartless mutum. Irin wannan categorical ra'ayi wahayi zuwa masu karatu, a duniya. "Shantaram" ya zama Popular a cikin kasar.

Rasha da kuma Indiya kasada

Komowa zuwa tambaya na yadda za a yi Rasha-harshe masu karatu wani labari game da wani Australian mai kasada, ya kamata ka ba 'yan dalilan da ya sa haka da kyau karanta a cikin kasar "Shantaram."

Littafi, sukar da waxanda suke quite rigima, ya zama mashahuri a Rasha a lokacin da ya zama gaye je India a gare ruhaniya ci gaba. "Shantaram" ya wani manufa mai shiryarwa a gare matafiya. A labari, akwai abubuwan da shekara talatin da suka wuce. Amma kadan ya canza tun sa'an nan, duka a Bombay isa tsere nuna a kan Roberts iyali. A samfurin wannan marubucin - na farko, kuma farkon wani littafin game da India. "Shantaram" cewa reviews yi ba ko da yaushe flattering, da yawa masu karatu yaba daidai saboda wannan kasa shi ne aka nuna a ta bambancin. Saboda haka game da India babu mawallafin ya ba tukuna aka posted.

Game da yadda za labari da aka haife

Kuma Roberts, kuma ya shahara harafin sau da dama a tsare. Daya mawallafin littafi, wanda shi ne, a wannan labarin, ya kasance a Kadaitaccen kurkuku. A irin wannan halin da ake ciki, mutane sau da yawa je mahaukaci. Roberts maƙwabcinsa a cikin masallãci, misali, amfani da su shirya kai hare-hare a kan kurkuku tsare duk lokacin da ka buɗe ƙofa zuwa ga ciki makõmarsu. Sai ya yanke shawarar ya taimake shi. Kowane dare, bayan fitilu fita, Roberts sanar da tunani makwabcin. Ba da da ewa shiga ta sauran fursunoni. Domin wannan taron ba ya bukatar jiki, ko ido lamba. Yana isa kawai don jin juna.

A watan baya, Roberts kirawo da ake kira neman. Ba tare da sanin abin da ya koyar da wasu fursunonin, sai ya tambaye shi ba don dakatar da yamma azuzuwan. Lalle ne, bayan da kurkuku fara yin zuzzurfan tunani, akwai wani kisan kai ko kai hare-hare. Robert cika da request, amma maimakon ya nemi wani alkalami da takarda. Ya yi ciyarwa a baya sanduna na dogon lokaci shekaru goma sha biyar.

The laifi duniya na Bombay

Koyaswarsa hidima na gwarzo sa wasu masu karatu korau motsin zuciyarmu. Shantarama Bugu da ƙari, cikin littafin yana mai yawa haruffa, farauta fataucin miyagun kwayoyi, da makamai ko jabun takardun. Marubucin na da sanannen littafin ya bayar da hujjar a cikin wata hira da ya haruffa da kome a cikin kowa da kananan 'yan fashi. Su ne 'yan mafia - da al'umma a cikin abin da na da dokoki da farillai. Duk da haka, ba kowane mai karatu shi ne m hali wanda aka kullum amfani da kwayoyi da kuma yin jayayya da a kan falsafa batutuwa. Wato, wadannan yafi hannu da heroes da kuma Roberts.

Akwai darajan karanta?

A imani da cewa "Shantaram" - mafi girma labari XXI, da ɗan karin gishiri. A kalla, cewa yana dauke da yawa sukar a Rasha. Amma yana da daraja idan akai la'akari da cewa marubucin wannan littafi - kada wani marubuci. A gagarumin bangare na rayuwa ya ciyar a kurkuku, da shan wahala daga miyagun ƙwayoyi buri, sayar da makamai, kuma suka yi jihãdi a cikin Afghanistan. A takaice, "da jami'o'i bai gama ba." Ko da masu karatu suke ba m game da littafin da wani tsohon fursuna, an wani lokaci da shawarar a karanta wannan muqala. Amma don gane "Shantaram", watakila, ya kamata ba kamar yadda wani aiki na gwaninta - kamar wani tarihin rayuwar mutum tare da wani matsanancin makoma. Roberts ziyarci slums na Bombay, shi aka sanya shi a cikin wani sansanin da kutare, daga abokai suka Afghanistan mãsu jihãdi. Akwai wuya mutum da irin wannan wani arziki biography na adabi duniya.

art siffofin

Abin da ya haddasa mummunan sake dubawa game da littafin Roberts? A mãkirci ne musamman miƙa. Shi yana da yawa haruffa cewa ba a tsare rawa. Son line, bisa ga masu karatu, kuma ba ya rike ruwa. Watakila saboda "Shantarama" ya zo a m labari. Amma kawai idan ta yanke a kalla a cikin rabin.

Yafi a cikin littafin Roberts ne India. Marubucin ya bayyana wannan ban mamaki kasa, ta hadisai da kuma al'adu. Isa a Mumbai, da gwarzo yana da 'yan kwanaki daga baya ya gane cewa kawai suke zaune a wannan birni ne ba zai yiwu ba. Kana bukatar ka zama wani ɓangare na shi, koyi ga rayuwa bisa ga dokokin. A littafin, dake nuna irin slums m ga m yankunan. Heroes Roberts - shi ne yadda mutane tãrãwa su burodi mai tsanani m aiki, da kuma mafia Figures.

Sulusin da labari da aka sadaukar domin zama gwarzo a Afghanistan. Wadannan surori wuya janye sha'awa har ma a tsakanin magoya na "Shantarama". Bayan duk, da hali na wannan littafin, kazalika da ta mahalicci, da aka fada a gefe na Mujahideen cewa zai iya sa da harshen Rashanci karatu ta tausaya.

dutsen inuwa

A shekarar 2015 shi da aka buga a ci gaba da labari game da Kasadar na Shantarama. Kamar yadda riga an ce, da laifi hanyar Roberts ne musamman arziki. Ya fasakwauri zinariya da takardar fasfot, ga safarar kwayoyi zuwa Turai. Amma a karshen na yanke shawarar karya tare da Mafia. Duk da haka, Roberts aka kama, kuma sun ciyar da dama more shekaru a Jamus kurkuku. A wadannan da kuma sauran abubuwan da suka faru na littafin "Shantaram-2."

Reviews na littafin "Shadow Mountain"

Bisa ga masu karatu na wannan aiki da dama plays "Shantaramu". A gwarzo ne guda, amma ya daina wani memba na mafia, kuma an haifar da mawallafin. A labari "Shadow Mountain" ba haka ba ne da yawa aukuwa cewa gaya game da kwastan na laifi duniya. Duk da haka, akwai wani mai haske launuka da kuma babbar sha'awa da kuma India, kyale Roberts farko labari ne don haka m da masu karatu.

Duk da bambanci ra'ayi game da halittar Gregori Devida Roberts, littafinsa da daraja karatu. Zai yiwu wadannan labaru ba za a iya kira mai wallafe-wallafen ayyukansu mawallafa - mai rai classic. Amma su ne ban sha'awa daga fahimi ra'ayi. Kuma godiya ga m labarin "Shantaram," wani labari taso cikin sha'awa na yan fim. A fim za a sake a 2017.